Skip to main content
  • The Rusty Nail logo top - Homepage
    The Rusty Nail logo scroll - Homepage
  • About
  • Drinks
  • WHISKEY MENU
  • Parties
  • Specials
  • SIDECAR MENU
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
The Rusty Nail logo top - HomepageThe Rusty Nail logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • About
  • Drinks
  • WHISKEY MENU
  • Parties
  • Specials
  • SIDECAR MENU

Whiskey Menu

  • North American Whiskies
  • Scotch
  • Irish, Japanese, & World Whiskies

Every Wednesday, from open to close, all 2oz pours of our whiskies, either neat or on the rocks, are 20% off! It's a great opportunity to grab a friend or three and taste through some bottles you're curious about, or revisit some old favorites. Please note: we update this list regularly, but sometimes we will have allocated or one-off bottles that do not appear here (BTAC, Van Winkle, etc), and occasionally we will have poured through our stock of a whiskey that is listed. Always feel free to ask your bartender if there's anything hiding in the back - you never know what we might have squirreled away!

Bourbon

Bourbon is the bulk of our whiskey selection and these are the legal rules: • Made anywhere in the USA, with a mash bill of grain containing at least 51% corn • Distilled no higher than 160 proof • Aged in new charred oak with an entry proof of 125 or lower • Bottled at 80 proof or higher • No added color or flavor (water may be added for proofing) • To be straight bourbon, it must be aged at least 2 years, in addition to the above rules. If any of the whiskey is aged less than 4 years, an age statement must be made on the bottle denoting the age of the youngest whiskey in the blend. The VAST majority of the American whiskies we carry are straight - it's a rigorous, well regulated standard that guarantees a certain level of quality. • To be bottled in bond/bonded, it must be aged at least 4 years, made in the same season by the same producer at the same distillery, and bottled at 100 proof, in addition to the above rules

1792 Small Batch

1792 Full Proof Rusty Nail Single Barrel Select

• We picked this barrel for it's notes of green candied apple, caramel corn, and crème brûlée. It's moderately hot at 120 proof, and a few drops of water open it up beautifully. It also makes an outstanding high-proof old fashioned!

1792 Sweet Wheat

1792 Bottled in Bond

1792 Single Barrel 98.6 proof

1792 12yr

Angel's Envy

Baker's 7yr

Balcones Pot Still Straight Bourbon

Barrell 9yr batch 14

Barrell 6yr batch 35

Barrell Amburana Cask Finish

Barrell Armida

Basil Hayden

Blade & Bow

Blanton's Single Barrel

Blanton's Gold Edition

Bond & Lillard no. 2

Booker's

Buffalo Trace

Castle & Key Small Batch

Chicken Cock Small Batch

Chicken Cock Double Oak

Cooper's Craft

Dark Arts 6.5yr French Oak

Dark Arts 6.5yr Cask Strength

EH Taylor Small Batch Bottled in Bond

Eagle Rare 10yr

Elijah Craig Small Batch

Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof

Elijah Craig 18yr

Evan Williams Bottled in Bond

Evan Williams 1783

FEW Bourbon

Four Roses Bourbon (Yellow)

Four Roses Small Batch Select

Four Roses Single Barrel

George Dickel 8yr Bourbon

Green River Straight Bourbon

Green River Wheated Bourbon

Green River Full Proof Bourbon

Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond

Henry McKenna 10yr Bottled in Bond

Hidden Barn Small Batch #5

Hirsch 8yr High Rye

IW Harper

Jefferson's Very Small Batch

Jefferson's Reserve

Jefferson's Tropics

Jefferson's Marian McLain

Jim Beam White Label

Jim Beam Black 7yr

Knob Creek 9yr

Larceny Small Batch

Larceny Barrel Proof

Longbranch

Maker's Mark

Maker's 46

Maker's 46 Cask Strength

Michter's US-1 Bourbon

Noah's Mill

Old Forester 86 proof

Old Forester 100 proof

Old Forester 1870 "Original Batch"

Old Forester 1897 Bottled in Bond

Old Forester 1910 "Old Fine Whisky"

Old Forester 1920 "Prohibition Style"

Old Forester Single Barrel Barrel Strength Louisiana Selection

Old Grandad Bottled in Bond

Old Soul

Old Soul High Rye Single Barrel

Old Soul Tintype Cask Strength

Penelope 4-Grain

Penelope Architect no. 11

Penelope Toasted Batch 24-303

Pinhook Bourbon Empire

Proof & Wood Representative

Rabbit Hole Cavehill

Rabbit Hole Dareringer PX Cask Finish

Rabbit Hole Heigold High Rye

Ragged Branch

Rare Stash

Redwood Empire Pipe Dream

J. Reiger Monogram

Rowan's Creek

Russell's Reserve 10yr Bourbon

Seven Three Bywater Bourbon

Seven Three Bywater 4-Grain

Seven Three Single Barrel New Orleans Bourbon Fest Selection '24

Smoke Wagon

Smooth Ambler Contradiction

Stellum Bourbon

Stellum Black Bourbon

Still Austin Straight Bourbon "The Musician"

Still Austin Cask Strength Bourbon

WB Saffell

Weller Special Reserve

Widow Jane "Baby Jane"

Widow Jane 10yr

Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon

Wild Turkey 70th Anniversary 8yr

Wild Turkey Rare Breed Bourbon

Wild Turkey Master's Keep "Unforgotten"

Wild Turkey Master's Keep "Voyage"

Wild Turkey Generations

Wilderness Trail Bottled in Bond Bourbon

Wilderness Trail Wheated Bottled in Bond

Willett 8yr Wheated Bourbon

Woodford Reserve

Woodford Reserve Double Oak

Wyoming Double Cask Bourbon

Rye

Using most of the same rules and regulations as bourbon, the main difference here is that the mash bill must contain at least 51% rye, rather than corn. Many ryes are "barely legal," meaning they're 51% rye with corn and malted barley making up the rest of the bill, but enough are 95% rye that those of us who are looking for that bold spice and herbaceousness have plenty of options.

Angel's Envy Rye

Balcones Rye

Bardstown Rye Origin

Barrell Seagrass

Cream of Kentucky Bottled in Bond

Dark Arts Amburana Stave Rye

Deadwood Rye

Elijah Craig Rye

FEW Rye

George Dickel Rye

George Dickel x Leopold Bros. 3 Chamber Still Collaboration

Green River Rye

High West Double Rye

Jack Daniel's Rye

Jack Daniel's Rye Bottled in Bond

Jefferson's Cognac Finish Rye

Knob Creek 7yr Rye

Masterson's 10yr Rye

Nelson Brothers Rye

Noble Oak Double Oak Rye

Old Forester Rye 100 proof

Old Overholt Rye Bottled in Bond

Peerless Rye

Pinhook Bourbon & Rye Lot 1

Pinhook Rye'd On '20

Pinhook Rye Humor Fall '18

Rabbit Hole Boxergrail Rye

Redwood Empire Emerald Giant Rye

Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond

Russell's Reserve 6yr Rye

Sagamore Signature 83 Rye

Sagamore Cask Strength Rye

Sagamore Double Oak Rye

Sagamore 9yr Rye

Sazerac Rye

Smokewagon Blender's Rye

Smooth Ambler Contradiction Rye

Stellum Rye

Stellum Black Rye

Still Austin Straight Rye "The Artist"

Tincup Rye

Uncle Nearest Rye

Whistle Pig Piggyback Rye

Whistle Pig Farmstock Rye

Whistle Pig 10yr Rye

Whistle Pig Old World 12yr Rye

Widow Jane Paradigm Rye

Wild Turkey 101 Rye

Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye

Wild Turkey Master's Keep "Cornerstone" Rye

Wilderness Trail Bottled in Bond Rye

Tennessee

What separates Tennessee whiskey from Bourbon? Coming off the still, it's exactly the same - 51% corn, 160 max distillation proof, 125 entry proof, etc., but besides the requirement that it be made in Tennessee, the Lincoln County Process makes it it's own thing. The Lincoln County Process is simple: the distillate is filtered through maple charcoal before barreling, helping the distillers remove undesirable flavors that they weren't able to cut from heart of the run.

George Dickel no. 12

George Dickel Bottled in Bond

George Dickel Barrel Select

George Dickel 15yr Single Barrel

George Dickel 17yr

Jack Daniel's no. 7

Jack Daniel's Bottled in Bond

Jack Daniel's Single Barrel

Nelson's Green Briar

Uncle Nearest 777

Other USA

From American single malts to mash bills that aren't legally categorized, this section is a catch all, but not to be missed - there are some amazing bottles in here that don't fit a tidy definition but that we think are pretty cool.

Balcones Baby Blue

Balcones Single Malt Whisky 1

Barrell Dovetail

J. Reiger Kansas City Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Triple Mash Bottled in Bond

Michter's US-1 American Whiskey

Redwood Empire Lost Monarch

Seven Three Irish Channel

Stranahan's Single Malt Empire State

Tincup American

Traveller

Uncle Nearest 1856

Westland Single Malt

Westward Single Barrel

Wyoming Outryder

Canada

Our friends to the North have a bit more leeway to hit the marks to legally call their products Canadian whiskey: the juice must be mashed, distilled and aged in Canada. It must be aged in "small wood vessels" for 3 or more years, be at least 80 proof, and "may contain caramel and flavoring" as long as that flavoring "possess[es] the aroma, taste and character generally attributed to Canadian whisky." As a result, most Canadian whiskey tends to be lighter in body, color, and flavor, making for an easy drinking spirit.

Crown Royal

Lot 40 Rye

Pendleton

Pendleton Midnight

Mexico

If you like whiskey with your corn, these are the pours for you. Big, specific, and unique, Mexican whiskey is bold, corny goodness.

Abasolo Ancestral Corn

Sierra Norte Yellow Corn

Every Wednesday, from open to close, all 2oz pours of our whiskies, either neat or on the rocks, are 20% off! It's a great opportunity to grab a friend or three and taste through some bottles you're curious about, or revisit some old favorites. Please note: we update this list regularly, but sometimes we will have allocated or one-off bottles that do not appear here, and occasionally we will have poured through our stock of a whiskey that is listed. Always feel free to ask your bartender if there's anything hiding in the back - you never know what we might have squirreled away! While we won't weigh in on where we think it originated, the fact is, whisk(e)y as we know and love it comes from the Scottish and Irish traditions. Offering an incredibly wide range of flavors based on region, mash bill, age, cask type, and distillery, there's a Scotch for just about everyone with an open mind and a curious palate. To qualify as Scotch, there are quite a few rules that must be followed, but the basics are: it must be made from malted barley (to which other grain may be added) that is processed, distilled, aged, bottled, and labeled in Scotland. It must come off the still at 190 proof or lower, be aged for at least 3 years in oak casks that are 700 Liters or smaller, and bottled at or above 80 proof/40% ABV, with the only allowed additives being water and caramel color. Single malt means that it's malt whisky - 100% malted barley - produced and bottled at a single distillery Single grain is malt whisky that has other cereal grain added to the mash, which is produced and bottled at a single distillery Blended malt is a blend of single malts from a variety of distilleries, etc..

Blends

Produced for consistency, blended Scotch - a mix of single malt and single grain Scotches from multiple distilleries - makes up the vast majority of Scotch production. While some might turn their noses up, there's a reason why it's so popular - you always know what you're going to get, and some of them are truly sublime.

The Deacon

Dewar's White Label

John Barr

Johnnie Walker Black

Johnnie Walker Blue

Johnnie Walker High-Rye

Monkey Shoulder

Mortlach

Highland

The largest and most productive of the Scotch regions, Highland whisky tends to be "fruity, sweet, spicy, and malty"

Clynelish 14yr

The Glendronach 18yr Allardice

The Glendronach 21yr Parliament

The Glendronach Cask Strength

Glenmorangie 10yr 86 Original

Glenmorangie 18yr

Oban 14yr

Oban Distillers Edition

Speyside

Until about 10 years ago, Speyside was considered part of the Highland region, but there's a wider variety of flavors found here, often being more robust than their former region-mates.

The Balvenie 12yr Double Wood

The Balvenie 14yr Caribbean Cask

The Balvenie 16yr French Oak

The Balvenie 21yr Port Wood

Glenfiddich 12yr Original

Glenfiddich 14yr Bourbon Barrel

Glenfiddich 21yr Gran Reserva

The Glengrant 12yr

The Glenlivet 12yr

The Glenlivet Caribbean Reserve

The Macallan 12yr

The Macallan 18yr

Islay

Are you looking for peat and brine? While a very few Islay Scotches are unpeated, the majority have a considerable amount of smoke both from the malting floor and from the water used to make the mash. Under that peat you'll find a wealth of complexity, but it can take some getting used to.

Bruichladdich Classic Laddie

Bruichladdich

Port Charlotte

Bruichladdich 18yr

Bruichladdich Octomore 12.1

Caol Ila 12yr

Lagavulin 8yr

Lagavulin 16yr

Laphroaig 10yr

Island

While not legally recognized as distinct from the Highland region, many drinkers consider the Islands to be their own thing. That said, there's a wide variety of flavor profiles with smokiness - sometimes heavy occasionally light - being a common thread

The Arran 10yr

Highland Park Cask Strength

Highland Park 12yr

Highland Park 15yr

Highland Park 18yr

Ledaig 19yr Marsala Cask

Talisker 10yr

Talisker Distillers Edition

Whether it's triple distilled in Ireland, Scotch-adjacent in Japan, breaking the mold in Taiwan, or something very French in France, whiskey is a world-wide, boundary pushing phenomenon

Ireland

Irish whiskey has an almost identical legal definition as Scotch, to the point that one can practically just switch one country with the other to define either one, so that's what I've done here, with a few minor adjustments: While we won't weigh in on where we think it originated, the fact is, whisk(e)y as we know and love it comes from the Scottish and Irish traditions. To qualify as Irish whiskey, there are quite a few rules that must be followed, but the basics are: it must be made from a mash of malted cereals (to which other whole grains may be added) that is processed, distilled, aged, bottled, and labeled in Ireland. It must come off the still at 189.6 proof or lower, be aged for at least 3 years in oak casks that are 700 Liters or smaller, and bottled at or above 80 proof/40% ABV, with the only allowed additives being water and caramel color. Single malt means that it's malt whiskey - 100% malted barley - produced and bottled at a single distillery Single grain is malt whiskey that has other cereal grain added to the mash, which is produced and bottled at a single distillery Single pot still is whiskey made at a single distillery using a mash of malted barley AND unmalted barley in a pot still. This produces a thicker, more robust whiskey than one using 100% malted barley and a column still. Like most Irish whiskey, this is typically triple distilled.

Bushmills Black Bush

Four Walls

Green Spot

Jameson

Jameson Triple Triple

Midleton Very Rare '22

Paddy's

Powers Gold Label

Redbreast 12yr

Redbreast 12yr Cask Strength

Redbreast Small Batch Cask Strength

Redbreast Kentucky Oak

Redbreast 21yr

Tullamore DEW

Yellow Spot

Japan

Based on the Scotch tradition, Japanese whisky is known for its nuance and complexity, along with the unique flavors imparted by the use of mizunara oak casks. While not the default option due to its rarity and cost, whiskies that are matured in mizunara have distinct and unique notes of sandalwood and coconut. The category took the world by storm in the very early aughts through the early '10s, with whiskies from Japanese distilleries winning top honors in international competitions time and again. In 2024, legislation was passed to regulate what can and cannot be labeled Japanese Whisky: the product must be fermented, distilled, aged and bottled in Japan, use some portion of malted grain in its mash, and use water sourced from Japan. Japanese whisky is fantastic in highballs. The addition of ice cold carbonated water and a lemon twist make the flavors pop and lengthen into a simple but remarkably refreshing cocktail.

Nikka Coffey Grain

Nikka Coffey Malt

Nikka From the Barrel

Yoichi

Miyagikyo

Taketsuru Pure Malt NAS

Taketsuru Pure Malt 17yr

Toki

Hibiki Harmony

Hakushu 12yr

Kaiyo Mizunara Cask Strength

Mars Iwai 45

Mars Iwai Tradition

Nobushi

Shibui Grain

Shibui Pure Malt

Shibui Pure Malt 10yr

Shinobu Pure Malt Mizunara

Tenjaku Blended

Taiwan

When people say Taiwan and whiskey in the same sentence, Kavalan immediately springs to mind. With a subtropical climate, mountain air, and ocean breezes, Taiwanese whiskey matures quickly and uniquely. That said, despite being one of the top consumers of single malt in the world, it's only been since 2002 that the private sector has been allowed to distill, and as a result, it has few distilleries and no standard definitions. As a result, the options are vast, and it's an exciting market to keep an eye on.

Kavalan King Car Conductor

Kavalan Solist PX Cask Strength

France

Despite an incredible tradition of distilling, France only began producing whisky in the early 80s. The category exploded, with over 100 distilleries today, and while there aren't a ton of exports, the one that we currently carry is rested in limousine oak and ex-cognac casks for 6 years, and is a real gem.

Brenne Estate Cask

  • Parties